Common Estimating Mistakes That Cost Builders Money

Back to Knowledge Hub

Why Accurate Estimating Is Critical for Profitability

For builders and contractors, the estimate is the foundation of every project. It determines whether you win the job, how much profit you make, and ultimately whether your business thrives or struggles. Yet despite its importance, estimating is one of the areas where mistakes are made most frequently, and those mistakes can be devastatingly expensive.

The challenge is that estimating errors rarely announce themselves. A missed item here, an outdated rate there, an overlooked preliminary cost somewhere else. Individually, these might seem minor. But when they compound across a project, the financial impact can be severe. A series of small oversights on a single job can easily wipe out your entire profit margin, leaving you working for weeks or months with nothing to show for it.

In this article, we look at the most common estimating mistakes we encounter when working with builders and contractors across the UK, and explain how each one can be avoided with the right approach and professional support.

Underestimating Preliminaries

Preliminaries are the costs associated with running a construction project that are not directly tied to the physical building work itself. They include items such as site setup, temporary welfare facilities, scaffolding hire, site insurance, skip hire, site security, temporary power supplies, and project management time. These are real, unavoidable costs that every project incurs, and they need to be accounted for in your estimate.

The problem is that many builders focus heavily on the measurable trade works, such as brickwork, carpentry and plumbing, but treat preliminaries as an afterthought. Some add a rough percentage on top. Others forget certain items entirely. The result is an estimate that looks competitive on paper but leaves significant costs unaccounted for.

A thorough estimate should itemise every preliminary cost individually. This includes not just the obvious items like scaffolding and skips, but also things like site signage, traffic management, temporary protection to existing surfaces, plant hire, fuel costs and even the time you spend managing the project and coordinating trades. When each cost is identified and priced separately, the risk of omission drops significantly.

Ignoring Specification Changes

Construction projects evolve. Between the initial design drawings and the final construction documents, specifications often change. Materials get upgraded, layouts are adjusted, structural details are revised, and new requirements emerge from building control or planning conditions. Each of these changes has a cost implication, and if your estimate is not updated to reflect them, you will be pricing work based on outdated information.

This is particularly common on projects where the design develops over several weeks or months. A builder might prepare an initial budget estimate based on early-stage drawings, and then carry that figure forward without revisiting it when the architect issues revised plans. By the time construction starts, the gap between the estimate and the actual cost of the revised design can be substantial.

The solution is straightforward but requires discipline. Every time a new drawing issue or specification change is received, the estimate should be reviewed and updated accordingly. This means re-measuring affected elements, checking for new items that have been introduced, and removing items that are no longer required. It is also worth maintaining a clear record of which drawing revision your estimate is based on, so there is never any ambiguity about what has been priced.

Using Outdated Rates

Material prices in the construction industry are not static. They fluctuate in response to supply chain conditions, raw material costs, energy prices, currency exchange rates and seasonal demand. In recent years, the pace of price changes has accelerated considerably, with some materials seeing increases of 20% or more within a single year. Labour rates also change, typically on an annual basis, as trade wages adjust and national insurance contributions are updated.

Despite this, many builders rely on rates from previous projects when preparing a new estimate. If you priced a similar job twelve months ago, it can be tempting to reuse those rates rather than obtaining fresh quotations. The problem is that a rate that was accurate last year may be significantly out of date today. Timber, steel, concrete, insulation, roofing materials and mechanical and electrical components are all subject to market-driven price movements.

A professional approach to estimating involves checking current market rates for all major materials and obtaining supplier quotations where possible. Labour rates should be reviewed against current industry benchmarks and adjusted for the specific location and complexity of the project. This takes more time than simply reusing old figures, but the accuracy it provides is essential for protecting your margins.

Forgetting Contingencies

No construction project goes exactly according to plan. There are always unknowns: unexpected ground conditions, hidden defects in existing structures, weather delays, supply chain disruptions, design queries that take time to resolve. These are not theoretical risks. They are everyday realities of building work, and a responsible estimate should make allowance for them.

A contingency allowance is a sum included in the estimate to cover unforeseen costs that cannot be specifically identified at the pricing stage. The appropriate level of contingency depends on the nature of the project. For a straightforward new build on a clear site with a fully detailed design, a contingency of 5% may be sufficient. For a renovation or refurbishment project involving work to an older building with limited survey information, 10% or more is often appropriate.

Omitting contingencies entirely is a gamble that rarely pays off. While it might make your price look more attractive in a competitive tender, it leaves you fully exposed to any cost that was not anticipated. When something unexpected does arise, and on most projects it will, you are left absorbing the cost from your own margin. Including a realistic contingency is not about padding the price. It is about being honest about the inherent uncertainty in construction and pricing accordingly.

Poor Measurement Takeoffs

The measurement takeoff is the process of calculating the quantities of materials and work items required from the construction drawings. It is the backbone of any estimate, and errors at this stage flow directly through to the final price. If you measure incorrectly, every rate you apply will be multiplied by the wrong quantity, compounding the error throughout the entire estimate.

Common measurement errors include misreading drawing scales, missing items that are shown on the drawings but not picked up during takeoff, double-counting elements that appear on multiple drawing sheets, and failing to account for waste. Waste factors vary by material but are a real cost that must be included. Brickwork typically requires a waste allowance of around 5%, while materials that require cutting, such as plasterboard, floor coverings and roofing tiles, may need 10-15% depending on the complexity of the layout.

Accurate measurement requires methodical working, a clear system for recording what has been measured, and careful cross-referencing between architectural, structural and services drawings to ensure nothing is missed. Digital takeoff tools can help reduce errors, but they are only as good as the person using them. There is no substitute for a thorough, disciplined approach to measurement, ideally carried out by someone with formal training in quantity surveying or estimating.

• Brickwork and blockwork: typically 5% waste allowance
• Timber and sheet materials: 10% waste allowance is common
• Plasterboard: 10-12% depending on room geometry
• Floor and wall tiles: 10-15% for cuts and breakages
• Roofing tiles and slates: 5-10% depending on roof complexity
• Concrete: 5-7% to account for over-ordering and spillage

How Professional Estimating Helps

Every one of the mistakes described above is avoidable, but avoiding them consistently requires time, expertise and a systematic approach that many busy builders and contractors simply cannot maintain alongside their day-to-day site responsibilities. This is where professional estimating services provide genuine value.

At First4Estimating, our qualified Quantity Surveyors prepare detailed, accurate estimates using current market rates, thorough measurement takeoffs and a structured approach that ensures nothing is overlooked. We work with builders and contractors of all sizes, from sole traders pricing their next job to established firms managing multiple projects simultaneously. Our estimating services cover everything from initial budget estimates through to full bills of quantities and tender documentation.

Whether you need a one-off estimate for a specific project or ongoing support through our subscription packages, outsourcing your estimating to a professional team means you can price with confidence, knowing that your estimates are thorough, accurate and based on current data. It removes the guesswork, reduces your risk, and frees up your time to focus on what you do best: building.